Have you ever had any of the following thoughts?
Why do I have to take required minimum distributions (RMDs) from my retirement account when I don’t need them? How much tax am I going to have to pay?
What is the best way to use my large IRA account ($1M+) to benefit my kids?
Does it make sense for me to consider doing Roth conversions?
My estate has grown considerably over the last five or so years. How is federal estate tax going to impact me? What if the exemption amounts go back down because the government needs more revenue?
If you have indeed had any or all of these thoughts, this month’s edition of Elevate Insights is for you.
Staying with the tax savings theme of our last couple of planning commentaries, this month I’m going to share a strategy designed to minimize income and estate taxes for people with large estates and significant retirement plan balances.
Full disclosure: Credit goes to McHenry Advisers, Inc. for developing this highly effective strategy which reduces required minimum distributions, increases flexibility, hedges against tax rate increases, and increases inheritance for heirs. It’s a Win-Win-Win for those whom it fits.
Why Large IRA Balances Can Create Tax Problems
Let’s dive right in. Most investors have been lectured ad-nauseum about asset diversification, which is indeed important (provided it’s not overdone), but very few advisors talk with their clients about asset location, which is also very important. Where assets are located impacts how they are taxed. Let’s quickly review current tax rates:
- Federal income tax: up to 37%
- State income tax: up to 13.3% depending on what state you are taxed in
- Capital gains and dividends tax: up to 23.8%
- Federal estate tax: 40% on your taxable estate which is your assets over $15M for single people and over $30M for married people
If you are not already aware, assets in tax deductible retirement plans like IRAs and other qualified plans (401k, SEP, SIMPLE, Profit Sharing, etc.) are taxed as ordinary income when withdrawn. Further, when you reach age 73 (currently), the IRS will force you to withdraw from such accounts whether you need or want the money. This is known as a Required Minimum Distribution (RMD). The withdrawal start age will change to 75 starting in 2035. When I say “force you to withdraw”, that simply means the money needs to come out of your account and be taxed. It doesn’t mean you have to put the cash in your bank account. People who don’t need the cash usually just move it to an individual account and leave it invested.
If you die with money remaining in an IRA or qualified plan having a named beneficiary, the beneficiary will need to take taxable distributions from the account over a period of time. The rules for this are complicated and beyond this discussion, but most people now get a 10 year window to withdraw the full account balance. This is often when child beneficiaries are in their peak earning years and paying the highest rates of tax.
IRA and other qualified plan balances are included in a person’s estate at death, and for those with estates large enough to be subject to federal estate taxes, the combined income and estate tax hit can be up to 70%. If that sounds high, IT IS! IRAs are the worst asset for wealth transfer. Even if you don’t have an estate large enough to be subject to federal estate tax, there is a far better way to arrange your assets than to simply subject yourself to the government’s plan for your money.
Introducing the Retirement Tax Minimization Strategy (RTMS)
Let’s talk about how the Retirement Tax Minimization Strategy (RTMS) works.
I’ll list the steps then discuss each one in more detail. For those of you who are allergic to the mention of life insurance, please stay with me and perhaps you will warm to the idea.
- Move IRA and/or other qualified plan assets into a tax qualified defined contribution plan that can legally own life insurance
- Acquire and fund a life insurance policy inside the tax-qualified defined contribution plan
- Buy the life insurance policy out of the plan and reposition to personal ownership or a grantor trust
Step 1: Move Retirement Assets Into a Qualified Defined Contribution Plan
Get your pre-tax retirement money into a tax-qualified defined contribution plan such as a profit sharing or money purchase plan, or a 401k whose plan document allows for the purchase of life insurance. The IRS allows transfers of this nature. Click here for details. You will need to have some sort of self-employment open such an account. Consulting income, a paid board seat, managing a real estate portfolio, teaching/instructing, and speaking are all examples of work that qualifies.
Step 2: Use Pre-Tax Plan Assets to Fund Life Insurance
The plan then applies for life insurance on the life of the account owner or for a survivorship policy that insures the account owner and spouse. The particulars of your situation will dictate which makes more sense. Once the policy is in place, the plan pays the premiums out of plan assets. Given the retirement plan account was funded with pre-tax dollars, this effectively makes the insurance premiums pre-tax which is normally not possible and is an enormous benefit as you will see. As premiums are paid over a number of years, by design, the plan assets subject to required minimum distributions (RMDs) are declining. This, in turn, causes the RMDs to be smaller and reduces the income tax paid on RMDs when they begin.
Step 3: Reposition the Policy Outside the Retirement Plan
After a period of time, typically five years, the account owner purchases the insurance policy from the plan for its fair market value. In this transaction, policy ownership changes from the plan to another entity, typically the account owner personally or a grantor trust established by the account owner. Cash goes into the account in return for the policy coming out. Since our goal is to minimize RMDs from the plan which in turn minimizes income taxes, keeping the fair market value of the policy low until the buyout occurs is desirable. There are insurance products designed for this purpose where the value is intentionally suppressed in the early years and grows rapidly in later years.
Note: Swap Cash Into Qualified Plan to Reposition Policy Out of Plan: DOL PTE 92-6 and Rev. Proc. 2005-25
Note: not all of the premiums paid for the life insurance policy will end up being paid with pre-tax dollars because the contribution to the plan to fund the policy buyout is made with post tax dollars.
Key Benefits of the Retirement Tax Minimization Strategy
Now, let’s review what we have accomplished.
Succinctly put, by being smarter than the average bear, we’ve transformed and multiplied a substantial number of fully taxable retirement dollars into a much larger pile of tax-free dollars.
Specifically,
- We’ve substantially reduced the balance in pre-tax retirement accounts that are fully taxable as ordinary income when withdrawn. As discussed, the government forces distributions upon attainment of age 73 whether you want or need the cash just so they can tax you.
- We’ve used these otherwise taxable dollars to fund life insurance that functions as a leveraging tool, by nature. Depending on age and health, $1 of funding can produce several dollars of tax-free death benefit.
- Positioned a life insurance policy into personal or trust ownership that will pay out a tax-free death benefit to whomever you name as beneficiary (ies).
- You pay less income tax, the government gets the shaft, and your kids, grandkids, and maybe favorite charities get multiple times more cash, free of tax, than they otherwise would. That is a highly effective winning strategy!
Putting some numbers to it:
60 year old in good health consolidates $4,000,000 of pre-tax retirement funds in tax qualified defined contribution plan.
Plan purchases a $21,100,000 life insurance policy on the life of the account owner and funds it with $800,000/yr for 5 years.
Account owner gifts $1,840,000 to his/her grantor trust to fund the eventual policy buyout.
After 5 years, grantor trust buys life insurance policy from the plan with the cash gifted to it.
This chart shows the impact of using the RTMS strategy to leave money to family vs following the government’s plan for your money.
As you might imagine, this is a great fit for people who:
- Have at least $1M in pre-tax retirement accounts they don’t expect to need for retirement
- Have liquidity available to buy the policy out of the plan
- Desire to minimize income and possibly estate taxes
- Want to maximize what they leave behind to kids, grandkids, charities
- Are in good enough health to qualify for life insurance
There is one maintenance item to be aware of to ensure the death benefit is tax free should you die while the life insurance policy is owned by your tax qualified defined contribution plan. While the policy is owned by the plan (but not after the buyout occurs) you must pay tax on what is called the reportable economic benefit provided by the plan. The IRS treats the insurance protection as a current taxable benefit when the plan is paying premiums on the policy with pre-tax dollars. You are taxed on what is referred to as the PS-58 amount which is a modest amount based on the pure insurance protection provided by the policy. The good news is that the cumulative taxes paid are considered basis and reduce the fair market value of the policy when it is purchased from the plan.
If you or someone you know may be a good fit for this strategy, call or email me to arrange some time to discuss how it could work for you.
Thank you for making time to read this edition of Elevate Insights. Feel free to reach out with questions, feedback or topics you would like us to cover in future months. Thank you and God bless.
Legal Information and Disclosures
This commentary expresses the views of the author as of the date indicated and such views are subject to change without notice. Elevate Capital Advisors, LLC ("Elevate") has no duty or obligation to update the information contained herein. This information is being made available for educational purposes only. Certain information contained herein concerning economic trends and performance is based on or derived from information provided by independent third-party sources. Elevate believes that the sources from which such information has been obtained are reliable; however, it cannot guarantee the accuracy of such information and has not independently verified the accuracy or completeness of such information or the assumptions on which such information is based. This memorandum, including the information contained herein, may not be copied, reproduced, republished, or posted in whole or in part, in any form without the prior written consent of Elevate. Further, wherever there exists the potential for profit there is also the risk of loss.
The Government Has a Plan for Your IRA — Here’s a Better One
Have you ever had any of the following thoughts?
Why do I have to take required minimum distributions (RMDs) from my retirement account when I don’t need them? How much tax am I going to have to pay?
What is the best way to use my large IRA account ($1M+) to benefit my kids?
Does it make sense for me to consider doing Roth conversions?
My estate has grown considerably over the last five or so years. How is federal estate tax going to impact me? What if the exemption amounts go back down because the government needs more revenue?
If you have indeed had any or all of these thoughts, this month’s edition of Elevate Insights is for you.
Staying with the tax savings theme of our last couple of planning commentaries, this month I’m going to share a strategy designed to minimize income and estate taxes for people with large estates and significant retirement plan balances.
Full disclosure: Credit goes to McHenry Advisers, Inc. for developing this highly effective strategy which reduces required minimum distributions, increases flexibility, hedges against tax rate increases, and increases inheritance for heirs. It’s a Win-Win-Win for those whom it fits.
Why Large IRA Balances Can Create Tax Problems
Let’s dive right in. Most investors have been lectured ad-nauseum about asset diversification, which is indeed important (provided it’s not overdone), but very few advisors talk with their clients about asset location, which is also very important. Where assets are located impacts how they are taxed. Let’s quickly review current tax rates:
If you are not already aware, assets in tax deductible retirement plans like IRAs and other qualified plans (401k, SEP, SIMPLE, Profit Sharing, etc.) are taxed as ordinary income when withdrawn. Further, when you reach age 73 (currently), the IRS will force you to withdraw from such accounts whether you need or want the money. This is known as a Required Minimum Distribution (RMD). The withdrawal start age will change to 75 starting in 2035. When I say “force you to withdraw”, that simply means the money needs to come out of your account and be taxed. It doesn’t mean you have to put the cash in your bank account. People who don’t need the cash usually just move it to an individual account and leave it invested.
If you die with money remaining in an IRA or qualified plan having a named beneficiary, the beneficiary will need to take taxable distributions from the account over a period of time. The rules for this are complicated and beyond this discussion, but most people now get a 10 year window to withdraw the full account balance. This is often when child beneficiaries are in their peak earning years and paying the highest rates of tax.
IRA and other qualified plan balances are included in a person’s estate at death, and for those with estates large enough to be subject to federal estate taxes, the combined income and estate tax hit can be up to 70%. If that sounds high, IT IS! IRAs are the worst asset for wealth transfer. Even if you don’t have an estate large enough to be subject to federal estate tax, there is a far better way to arrange your assets than to simply subject yourself to the government’s plan for your money.
Introducing the Retirement Tax Minimization Strategy (RTMS)
Let’s talk about how the Retirement Tax Minimization Strategy (RTMS) works.
I’ll list the steps then discuss each one in more detail. For those of you who are allergic to the mention of life insurance, please stay with me and perhaps you will warm to the idea.
Step 1: Move Retirement Assets Into a Qualified Defined Contribution Plan
Get your pre-tax retirement money into a tax-qualified defined contribution plan such as a profit sharing or money purchase plan, or a 401k whose plan document allows for the purchase of life insurance. The IRS allows transfers of this nature. Click here for details. You will need to have some sort of self-employment open such an account. Consulting income, a paid board seat, managing a real estate portfolio, teaching/instructing, and speaking are all examples of work that qualifies.
Step 2: Use Pre-Tax Plan Assets to Fund Life Insurance
The plan then applies for life insurance on the life of the account owner or for a survivorship policy that insures the account owner and spouse. The particulars of your situation will dictate which makes more sense. Once the policy is in place, the plan pays the premiums out of plan assets. Given the retirement plan account was funded with pre-tax dollars, this effectively makes the insurance premiums pre-tax which is normally not possible and is an enormous benefit as you will see. As premiums are paid over a number of years, by design, the plan assets subject to required minimum distributions (RMDs) are declining. This, in turn, causes the RMDs to be smaller and reduces the income tax paid on RMDs when they begin.
Step 3: Reposition the Policy Outside the Retirement Plan
After a period of time, typically five years, the account owner purchases the insurance policy from the plan for its fair market value. In this transaction, policy ownership changes from the plan to another entity, typically the account owner personally or a grantor trust established by the account owner. Cash goes into the account in return for the policy coming out. Since our goal is to minimize RMDs from the plan which in turn minimizes income taxes, keeping the fair market value of the policy low until the buyout occurs is desirable. There are insurance products designed for this purpose where the value is intentionally suppressed in the early years and grows rapidly in later years.
Note: Swap Cash Into Qualified Plan to Reposition Policy Out of Plan: DOL PTE 92-6 and Rev. Proc. 2005-25
Note: not all of the premiums paid for the life insurance policy will end up being paid with pre-tax dollars because the contribution to the plan to fund the policy buyout is made with post tax dollars.
Key Benefits of the Retirement Tax Minimization Strategy
Now, let’s review what we have accomplished.
Succinctly put, by being smarter than the average bear, we’ve transformed and multiplied a substantial number of fully taxable retirement dollars into a much larger pile of tax-free dollars.
Specifically,
Putting some numbers to it:
60 year old in good health consolidates $4,000,000 of pre-tax retirement funds in tax qualified defined contribution plan.
Plan purchases a $21,100,000 life insurance policy on the life of the account owner and funds it with $800,000/yr for 5 years.
Account owner gifts $1,840,000 to his/her grantor trust to fund the eventual policy buyout.
After 5 years, grantor trust buys life insurance policy from the plan with the cash gifted to it.
This chart shows the impact of using the RTMS strategy to leave money to family vs following the government’s plan for your money.
As you might imagine, this is a great fit for people who:
There is one maintenance item to be aware of to ensure the death benefit is tax free should you die while the life insurance policy is owned by your tax qualified defined contribution plan. While the policy is owned by the plan (but not after the buyout occurs) you must pay tax on what is called the reportable economic benefit provided by the plan. The IRS treats the insurance protection as a current taxable benefit when the plan is paying premiums on the policy with pre-tax dollars. You are taxed on what is referred to as the PS-58 amount which is a modest amount based on the pure insurance protection provided by the policy. The good news is that the cumulative taxes paid are considered basis and reduce the fair market value of the policy when it is purchased from the plan.
If you or someone you know may be a good fit for this strategy, call or email me to arrange some time to discuss how it could work for you.
Thank you for making time to read this edition of Elevate Insights. Feel free to reach out with questions, feedback or topics you would like us to cover in future months. Thank you and God bless.
Ken Armstrong, CFP®, RICP®, ChFC®, CLU®, CASL®, CLTC
Co-Founder, CEO, Senior Wealth Advisor
Legal Information and Disclosures
This commentary expresses the views of the author as of the date indicated and such views are subject to change without notice. Elevate Capital Advisors, LLC ("Elevate") has no duty or obligation to update the information contained herein. This information is being made available for educational purposes only. Certain information contained herein concerning economic trends and performance is based on or derived from information provided by independent third-party sources. Elevate believes that the sources from which such information has been obtained are reliable; however, it cannot guarantee the accuracy of such information and has not independently verified the accuracy or completeness of such information or the assumptions on which such information is based. This memorandum, including the information contained herein, may not be copied, reproduced, republished, or posted in whole or in part, in any form without the prior written consent of Elevate. Further, wherever there exists the potential for profit there is also the risk of loss.
Ken Armstrong, CFP®, RICP®, ChFC®, CLU®, CASL®, CLTC
Share
More Commentary
The Market Needs a Tic Tac
The Market’s Still Climbing, But So Are the Risks
Tax Planning for High Earners: Strategies Beyond Maxing Out Your 401(k)